This is my introduction to Cabello’s work, and it’s abundantly obvious that she is very talented singer, capable of conveying complex emotion that can be amplified and minimized when appropriately needed. In just one song, you can very clearly tell her potential as a vocal performer. One of my favorite oddball-pop stars, Sia, is supposedly credited as the writer, and that is apparent in the song’s actual competent progression and structure.
The fantastic violin introduction is very inviting, and Cabello’s vocal talent is very quickly displayed, but the way she is singing is extremely overplayed by this point in popular music. Whatever identity she has, unfortunately, overshadowed by the ever prevalence of singers who sing in the exact same cadence and slang-y style that she does. Obviously fans more familiar with her early work will be able to look past this, most likely, but I cannot at the moment.
The “I have questions” line only gets more annoying the more it’s said, ruining what I enjoyed about the introduction.
The sample that kicks in around the 2 minute mark just instantly takes me away from any attention I was giving the song, and takes me out to thinking about either Genie in a Bottle or that new Ed Sheeran song that just irritates me. Not a terrible choice, but feels really lazy, and unimpressive. The successful buildup of the beginning of the song just leads us to an underwhelming and bare xylophone-sounding section where we are supposed to feel like “ALL MY PROBLEMS ARE GONE NOW THAT I’M IN THE CLUB, I CAN’T CRY HERE, JUST PARTY, I’M IN DENIAL, ISN’T THAT SHIT DEEP?”. I would just be expecting something heavier, bass-ier, or maybe faster, instrumentally, at this section, to better construct the illusion of trying to get lost in a club after a break-up.
I can appreciate that the song has a theme, but less than half-way through it fails to really match-up musically to that theme’s progression in the track as well as it could have.
Not a bad song by any stretch of the imagination, will likely be loved her fans, just disappointing, underwhelming, and kinda instrumentally unoriginal considering the clear level of talent involved in it’s construction.